An Ode to Gelato: Exploring Italy’s Sweetest Temptation

If people know one thing about me, it’s my love for gelato. When I arrive in Italy, scoping out one of my favorite gelaterias is always at the top of my list. My love affair is so strong that if I don’t post my classic photo proudly displaying my first gelato stop of the trip on social media within a couple of days of arriving in Italy, my friends honestly think something is wrong with me and are relieved when that photo is posted!

I have been traveling to Italy for over 23 years and can proudly say that I have become a true Gelato Queen and am picky about where I indulge in this delectable treat. I am known to go to my favorite gelato spot in Florence three times in one day. Yes, three times – breakfast, lunch and dinner! They know me well. Follow me, and you’re guaranteed a gelato stop – or two – on all my Italy trips!

While you’ve more than likely heard of gelato before and hopefully tasted some, we’re going to break it down by explaining what makes gelato special, looking into some of the history behind this creamy delight, and letting you in on some insider tips to finding the best gelato in Italy. Be sure to read until the end for some of my favorite gelato spots in Italy!

History of Gelato

Gelato, the frozen delight that enchants palates worldwide, has a rich history steeped in tradition and innovation. Embark on a journey back in time as we unveil the roots of gelato and trace its captivating evolution.

From the snow-laden landscapes of China to the sweet concoctions of Persia, the idea of crafting frozen treats has been a cherished secret shared across continents. The origins of gelato can be traced back to the ancient civilizations of Persia, where ice and snow were combined with fruit juices to create an early form of a chilled treat. A similar idea was prevalent in medieval courts, where chefs created “sorbetto” – an early form of gelato – using snow and fruit juices to delight royalty.

As the centuries unfolded, gelato moved from palatial tables to the charming streets of Italy’s towns and cities. The evolution continued as gelato artisans refined their techniques, embracing new equipment and ingredients while holding steadfast to the cherished old practices. Today, gelaterias across Italy continue to honor this sweet evolution, offering a taste of the past and the present in every spoonful.

Ice Cream vs. Gelato: What’s the Difference?

In the world of frozen desserts, the distinction between gelato and ice cream extends beyond mere semantics. Explore the nuances that set these two beloved treats apart, from their ingredients and preparation to their sensory experience.

Dairy, Fat, Air & Eggs

Ice cream is made using heavy cream, while gelato is traditionally made using milk. You will also find eggs listed as an ingredient in most ice creams, while gelatos do not typically contain eggs. Gelato also boasts a lower fat content than ice cream (2 to 9% for gelato vs. 10 to 25% for ice cream). The churning process is faster for ice cream, which results in more air, giving it a lighter feel and characteristic fluffiness. Gelato is churned slower and contains less air. 


The differences in ingredients and process explain the difference in textures – where ice cream is fluffy and icy, gelato is dense, silky and smooth.

Serving Tool

While ice cream is generally served with a classic scooper, authentic gelato is served using a flat spatula. These spatulas scrape gelato into cones or cups, often serving two flavors together. It’s also important to note that gelato should not be hard enough to be balled or stacked.


Finally, gelato is known to have a more intense flavor than ice cream. This is again due to how it’s made, a direct result of minimal air incorporation in the final product. 

In essence, the differences between gelato and ice cream extend beyond the surface, encompassing factors such as composition, temperature, texture, and how they captivate our taste buds. Whether it’s gelato’s denser intensity or ice cream’s indulgent creaminess, both frozen treats offer a delightful culinary experience that reflects the cultural nuances and gastronomic creativity they embody.

How to Find Authentic Gelato in Italy

Navigating the bustling streets of Italy in search of the perfect gelato is an adventure that demands discernment and a keen eye for authenticity. Pursuing genuine gelato takes us beyond mere storefront appearances into the heart of traditional craftsmanship and flavor integrity.

The following are some of our top tips for finding Italy’s best, most authentic gelato:

Look for muted colors, and avoid anything bright or neon. 

Authentic gelato is made with natural, seasonal ingredients. This means that the colors of gelato should mimic nature and will often be dull rather than bright and vibrant. Pistachio gelato should never be bright green, nor should strawberry gelato be super red. 

Avoid mountains of gelato. 

Tall, fluffy gelato that doesn’t melt is a tactic to attract customers. This actually means that the gelato is likely full of air, vegetable fats and emulsifiers. 

Look for gelato in stainless steel tubs with lids.

Storing gelato in stainless steel tubs is a good sign of a higher-quality gelateria and is far preferred to plastic tubs. Lids mean the gelato is kept at the right temperature; therefore, out-of-sight is better where gelato is concerned!

Look for signs that say ‘gelato in casa’, ‘fatto in casa’, or ‘gelato artigianale.’

Authentic, artisan gelaterias often advertise that their sweet treats are made in-house. Don’t decide based on this alone; consider it a good sign!

Check out the ingredient list.

Every Italian gelateria is required to display its ingredients. Here are some questions to consider: How long is the list? Are there ingredients such as vegetable oil or artificial flavors and colors? Was the list hidden, or did you have to ask for it?

Pay attention to the flavors offered.

As with most Italian cuisine, gelato flavors are usually seasonal. Fruit flavors should be what’s in season – base this on the fruit you can currently find at a local farmer’s market. Avoid tourist flavors not made with naturally available ingredients, such as bubblegum and cotton candy.

Look beyond the vibrant and extravagant displays that beckon from every corner. Authentic gelaterias prioritize natural ingredients and showcase their creations simply, letting the flavors speak for themselves. 

Another great piece of advice is to trust local recommendations and seek out spots frequented by residents. Lines forming outside a gelateria are a promising sign, indicating its popularity among locals who know where to find the best. If language barriers pose a challenge, observe where Italians choose to indulge – they are connoisseurs who understand the true essence of gelato.

In pursuing authentic gelato, embrace curiosity and a sense of adventure. The journey to discovering genuine Italian gelato is as much about savoring the flavors as it is about immersing yourself in the art of true craftsmanship.

My Favorite Gelato Spots in Italy

As a self-proclaimed Gelato Queen with over two decades of culinary exploration, I’ve traversed the charming streets of Italy in search of the creamiest, most delightful gelato experiences. Allow me to share my favorites, carefully curated to ensure you experience the best gelato Italy offers.

Without further ado, here are some of my absolute favorite gelato spots in Italy:


Vestri Cioccolato d’Autore – Borgo Degli Albizi 11r

Gelateria Della Passera – via Toscanella, 15/red

Venchi Gelato and Chocolate – via Calimaruzza, 18 & via Calzaiuoli, 65r

Perchè No – via dei Tavolini, 19r


Baffone Gelateria Artigianale – via Roma, 48

Embarking on Your Gelato Journey

Are you ready to elevate your gelato adventure to a new level of luxury and culinary excellence? Our carefully curated culinary tours offer a seamless blend of exploration, education, and indulgence. Join fellow connoisseurs as we traverse Italy’s charming cities, seaside towns, and hidden alleys in pursuit of the finest dining experiences. Led by knowledgeable guides, our tours delve into the artistry, history, and culture of Italy and its food, providing a deeper understanding of this country’s delectable cuisine. Immerse yourself in the heart of Italy’s culinary heritage, and let every bite be a step toward creating lasting memories. 

Join one of our Delectable Destinations tours to Italy if you want to discover more about this incredible country, try some of the best food it offers, and delight in some exquisite gelato along the way!

Like this article?

Share on Facebook
Share on Twitter
Share on Linkdin
Share on Pinterest